Sept 2026 · 3 min read

Pacifiers: Which Ones Babies Actually Keep In

We tested seven pacifiers on three newborns. Four got spit across the room within a week. Here's what separated the survivors.

What to look for

  • One-piece silicone. No seams, no crevices, nothing to pull apart. Dishwasher-safe.
  • The right size. 0–3 month pacifiers are smaller and lighter. A too-big paci gets pushed out by the tongue.
  • Vented shield. Keeps drool from pooling and causing rash.
  • Buy multiples of the winner. Once baby picks one, you want six of it. Not six different ones.
  • A clip. Not optional once you're in the car. Infantino's 3-pack fits every pacifier.

The survivors

  1. Philips Avent Soothie. Same shape most maternity wards hand out, so there's no relearning. Our top pick.
  2. Dr. Brown's HappyPaci. Shaped like a bottle nipple. Bottle-fed babies take it instantly.
  3. BIBS. Round natural-rubber shield, the one in every stroller photo. Pricier, and some babies love it.
Tip: If you're breastfeeding, most lactation consultants suggest waiting until feeding is established (often 3–4 weeks) before introducing a pacifier. Ask yours.

Get the Car Seat & Stroller Kit

As an Amazon Associate, Stuff4Baby earns from qualifying purchases made through links in this post, at no cost to you.